After an episode that strong, “Recall Vote” was bound to suffer in comparison—but not by much. Directed by Wendey Stanzler and written by Aisha Muharrar (another long-timer, who wrote one of my favorite episodes, the birther send-up “Born & Raised”), this one finds Leslie distracting herself on recall vote day by working on the City Hall Haunted House (and, obviously, Kevin Pollak’s birthday), only to end the day getting roundly voted out.
Confession: this viewer was a little blind-sided by that turn. I frankly expected her to pull it out in a squeaker—she is our protagonist, after all—so hats off to the show for having the stones to go in that darker direction without blinking (or pulling out some sort of eleventh-hour reversal). It may not be the easy way to go, but it allows the show to take some interesting turns: by giving us Depressed Leslie, declaring “Nothing matter any more” between bites of her early morning Paunch Burger and penning a concession speech that is, well, pointed (“Eat my shorts, Jabronies. Knope out!”). Even a paper mache Lil’ Sebastian can’t cheer her up.
Yet though we feel bad for Leslie, her spiral allows her to pull Ben down with her (“Oh God, did I peak when I was 18?” “There it is! Drink up”) and to give us the hilarity of the utterly hammered couple declaring their love for each other and going for tattoos (“Tattoos? This is a pawnshop. But yeah, I can do that”).
The B- and C-plots, concerning Ron’s sudden endorsement from the local lifestyle blog Bloosh and Tom’s attempt to ride that train to a last-ditch Rent-A-Swag save, are funny (even if insipid Annabel’s dopey “picks” are a parody of Ophah’s “Favorite Things” that was done, and better, clear back in 30 Rock’s third season). Yet the heart of this episode is Leslie’s fall, and her inevitable rise from the ashes. Ann’s real talk scene with Leslie is warm and lovely, and a reminder of what we’re losing when she takes off in a few episodes (I’m starting to rethink my blasé attitude about that exit). Without her, the Leslie Knope Emotional Support Task Force will be down to only one member, and let’s face it, no one can handle that job alone.