10 Must-See Movies at This Year’s New York Film Festival


The 56th annual New York Film Festival kicks off tomorrow night at Lincoln Center with a big, splashy opening night screening of The Favourite, the new laugh riot from Yorgos Lanthimos. Over the two-plus weeks that follow, festival-goers will sample a selection of some of the most invigorating foreign, independent, and documentary titles of the year — everything from to-the-minute docs to the 40-years-in-the-making final film by the legendary Orson Welles. In fact, let’s start our preview there…

The Other Side of the Wind

The fabled, long-incomplete final feature film by Orson Welles spends far too much of its opening explaining itself, with a scrolling text of its history followed by a redundant and shabbily assembled opening sequence, with a new in-character voice-over by Peter Bogdanovich pasting together images from the movie — basically, an illustration of the worst fears of what this posthumous paste job could be. Thankfully, that’s all over quickly; the film itself is fascinating snapshot of the filmmaker in his twilight, full of arresting images and sharp subtext (particularly vis-a-vis his complicated relationship with Bogdanovich, a pupil who quickly surpassed his teacher in power and influence). It helps to know the movie’s wild background and the filmmaker’s late style, since it is often a messy and uneven piece of work. But then again, pretty much everything he made after Touch of Evil was, those Scotch-tape jobs rendered vital by their flashes of brilliance. And there are plenty of those in The Other Side of the Wind.

They’ll Love Me When I’m Dead

Morgan Neville’s new documentary focuses on the making and aftermath of Other Side of the Wind, and its side-by-side appearance on the festival circuit (and, in November, on Netflix) is wise; it fills in the gaps that might leave casual viewers of the Welles film baffled. But Neville (Oscar winner for 20 Feet from Stardom) is no slouch, and this isn’t just a special feature — it’s a portrait of a hustler/genius, a celebration of his work, and a valentine to Gary Graver, the cinematographer whose dedication and perseverance kept the project going for all those years. Playfully edited with clips from the entire Welles oeuvre, and loaded up with great outtakes and archival interviews (including one, with a French reporter, that Welles conducts entirely in her native tongue), They’ll Love Me is, in many ways, more purely enjoyable than its subject.

Her Smell

Alex Ross Perry’s latest is a magnificently visceral portrait of a Courtney Love-ish riot grrrl (Elisabeth Moss, murdering) on the down slope of a tempestuous career, who has to get clean and get her life together for the sake of her young daughter. What sounds like every damn music and addiction redemption story ever is rendered fresh and bloody by the immediacy of Moss’s playing and Perry’s execution; it’s a story told in just a handful of scenes, in which her on- and off-stage meltdowns and tantrums are allowed to play out roughly in real time, offering no escape hatch for the viewer. The result is one of the most convincing portraits I’ve seen of a person out of control — and of the way an entire support system is built around celebrities, to keep them from ever knowing how impossible they’ve become.


Paul Dano’s feature directorial debut — penned with his partner Zoe Kazan — is adapted from Richard Ford’s novel, but it feels more like a short story. That’s meant as compliment; this is a keenly observed snapshot of a tiny but pivotal moment in several lives, chief among them young Joe (Ed Oxenbould, wonderfully reactive), his mother Jeanette (Carey Mulligan, exceptional), and his father Jerry (Jake Gyllenhaal, on a hot streak this fall). It’s less about what happens to them than the feelings of being along for the ride, watching in horror as a parent goes sideways, sinks into desperation, or simply makes you aware — perhaps for the first time — that they’re even more of a mess than you are. The central metaphor is a little cumbersome, but Dano has a good eye for simple, loaded images, and knows how to get the best from his actors.


Monrovia, Indiana

Frederick Wiseman has always been an observational filmmaker, and his latest does not break that mold; he rambles through a small town in Indiana, giving us a series of wide shots (buildings, streets, homes), occasionally settling on one and peeking in for a bit. He sees Bible studies, school lessons, and city planning meetings; he watches a concert (where the orchestra class plays a pokey version of The Simpsons theme) in a high school gym, then returns there several weeks later for a mattress sale, somehow. He’s always resisted making grand statements, at least explicitly — there are no talking head interviews or voice-over narrators to tell us what it all means — but the amount of time he spends at a funeral near the film’s conclusion says all he needs to say.



After two runs around the dance floor with Kristen Stewart, director Olivier Assayas is back with perhaps the Frenchest of his films to date, a chatty, smart movie about intelligent yet self-sabotaging people. Its subjects are all in entertainment, publishing, or politics, and the clever script explores the ways in which the lines between those three fields have blurred; they have affairs and disappoint each other, and in between there are heady conversations about algorithms, criticism, targeted marketing, and binge-watching. It’s a rare movie that gets how these kind of people really talk, how theorizing and proclamation masquerades as conversation, and (as ever) Assayas has a keen ear for the way people who care about each other are uniquely equipped to cut each other to ribbons.

Courtesy of Cohen Media Group


Ash Is Purest White

Jia Zhangke and his frequent collaborator (and wife) Zhao Tao reteam for this story of a gentleman gangster’s moll who ends up doing five years for him, and finds herself reentering the world on very different terms. Zhangke experiments energetically with tone and tempo, stretching her story across a decade and a half, with flavors of gangster movie, prison drama, and romantic melodrama. Ultimately, it’s a story of forgiveness — of finding the strength to be your own person, and using that strength for good.


Long Day’s Journey Into Night

Bi Gan’s half-3D drama is a Mobius loop of past and present, in which, as one character puts it, “Memories mix truth and lies, they appear and vanish before our eyes.” A young man attempts to track down his recently deceased father’s great lost love, his quest intermingling with her past in unexpected, dreamlike ways. It’s moody as hell — the voice-over is hushed and enigmatic, the musical score is languid, and it’s always raining — but never forced or derivative, a journey picture played out in impeccably controlled long takes and images that live in a space between daydream and hallucination.


This character-driven drama from director Lee Chang-Dong is one of those films that genuinely benefits from going in cold — I knew nothing whatsoever about it going in, and thus its pivot from a melancholy romance to unnerving mystery was genuinely surprising and undeniably affecting. Chang-Dong works in a meandering style, in which you’re not really certain where he’s going until he gets there, but you’re also never really worried, so striking are the images and compelling are the relationships. All three of these fine Asian features are pointedly unpredictable, all but gear-shifting into different films throughout their expansive running times, and this is a trend American cinema would be wise to emulate.

In My Room

One of the best bait-and-switches in recent memory comes about 30 minutes into this effort from German writer/director Ulrich Köhler, who sets up what looks very much like a cringe comedy about a daft screw-up (Hans Löw) tanking his job while alienating his friends and family. And then, one morning he wakes up and… everyone’s gone. There’s no power, no water, and no other people; the highways are littered with abandoned cars and free-range wild animals. And it turns out, he’s a much better, happier person when no one else is around. Köhler nimbly shifts from observation to nihilism to optimism, and works through the particulars of his predicament without ever really explaining it. (Rapture? Vanishing? Who knows!) A warped yet funny piece of work, with some turns that really catch you unawares.

The New York Film Festival runs September 28 through October 14; more information here, and more reviews to come.